Are Wider Car Tires Better Than Narrow Car Tires? | Pros & Cons

Disclaimer: carsreborn.com participant in the Amazon Associates Program. This means that qualifying purchases made through our Amazon.com links may result in a commission for us. This no extra cost to you.

When it comes to tire replacement, you may think, are wider car tires better than narrow car tires? There is a lot of debate about what width is the most efficient. Depending on the terrain and weather conditions, you have to choose the right tire for your car.

These two tires have different fuel economies, speed, traction, and maneuverability. Wider car tires have pros and cons, and narrow car tires have pros and cons.

If you want improved traction, handling, and fuel efficiency, consider upgrading to wider tires on your car. You may be surprised at how much of a difference they can make. In this blog post, we will explore are wider car tires better than narrow car tires. Why may they be a better choice for your vehicle?

Wider Car Tires vs Narrow Car Tires

Are Wider Car Tires Better Than Narrow Car Tires?

Narrower tires are often thought to be more efficient because they create less drag, are faster, and are easier to maneuver. However, wider tires provide more traction due to their larger surface area. Additionally, wider tires distribute the vehicle’s weight more evenly, which leads to improved handling and stability. Lastly, wider tires can create less drag and slightly reduce fuel efficiency. We can compare wider car tires to narrow car tires in terms of fuel economy, handling performance, speed, traction, weather (dry and wet), comfortability, wearing, and price.

 

Fuel Economy.

Wider tires contact a larger surface area than narrow car tires. When the tire touches more surface area, it creates more traction. Therefore wider tires require more power to accelerate. So it uses more horsepower. However, narrow tires vs wide tires have a negligible fuel economy.

 

Handling Performance.

Wider tires touch more surface area and have more traction than narrow wheels. Therefore this will improve the car’s overall handling and quartering performance.

 

Speed difference.

Tire width does not affect the car’s speed. However, when choosing different width wheels, if it changes the sidewall height, it changes the overall tire height; this will change the actual speed and speedometer speed.

If sidewalls have the same ratio but if the tire’s width is different, then such wider tires are taller and slightly faster. For instance, choosing a 245/75-16 vs 265/75-16 tire (same sidewall ratio) changes the tire’s overall sidewall height and diameter. However, selecting 245/75-16 vs 255/70-16 (different sidewall ratio) doesn’t change the tire sidewall and overall diameter.

When choosing wider and narrow tires, there is no speed difference if the overall height doesn’t change. Use our free tire size comparison calculator to check speed differences and more details.

 

Friction.

In this situation, friction is calculated by force (weight) put on the ground. Narrow tires have higher friction than wider tires. Because thin wheels have less contact surface area, it has a higher weight per square inch. On the other hand, a wider tire touches a larger contact patch. Therefore, it puts less weight per square inch. Thus when it reduces per square inch weight, it reduces the friction.

Reduced friction is one of the advantages of wider tires. However, this can be a con of wider tires in winter.

 

Wet driving conditions.

On wet driving roads, narrow wheels perform better than wider wheels. This is because a wider tire has more contact patches with the ground. Due to that reason, it has a smaller weight per square inch. The narrow tire has a relatively small contact patch due for that reason it has a more considerable weight per square inch. So in slippery wet driving conditions, narrow tires put more pressure on the ground to provide better performance.

If the narrow tires improve the tire’s grip but less traction. Therefore narrow tires are safe in wet conditions.

 

Snow driving conditions.

In snow weather, narrow tires perform better than wider tires. If you wish to use an all-season tire in the winter season, use narrow tires rather than wider ones. The narrow tire has a smaller contact patch. Therefore, it has a higher weight per square inch. This will improve the tire friction in slippery driving conditions.

Snow tires are specifically designed for driving under extreme freezing climates (snow, ice, and slush), but all seasons wheels can perform icy conditions.

 

wider wheels on snowy road
Wider wheels on a snowy road.

 

Comfortability.

When the tire has a higher sidewall, it can absorb the shocks than the lower sidewall tires. Generally, flat tires have lower sidewalls, and therefore narrow tires are more comfortable than flat tires.

 

Wearing.

Tire wearing increases the braking and cornering. The wider tire has a broader contact patch than slim tires. More contact patch means less weight on squire inch (low pressure on the surface). Less weight per squire inch has less friction. So if we consider all other conditions are constant, wider tires wear slower than narrow tires.

 

Thin tires vs thick tires Pros and Cons.

Thin tires Thick tires
SpeedNormalSlightly faster
Driving ConditionPerform better in wet and snow roadsPerform better in dry roads
ComfortabilityMore comfortableLess comfortable
PriceCheaperExpensive

 

Why are wider tires more efficient than narrower tires?

Wider tires offer several advantages that narrower tires cannot match. First, they provide more traction due to their larger surface area, and this makes them ideal for off-road driving and other challenging terrains. Additionally, wider tires distribute the vehicle’s weight more evenly, which leads to improved handling and stability. Lastly, wider tires can create less drag and improve fuel efficiency.

Narrower tires may have some advantages, such as increased fuel efficiency and less drag. However, the benefits of wider tires make them the clear choice for many drivers. If you are looking for improved traction, handling, and fuel efficiency, consider upgrading to wider tires on your next vehicle. You may be surprised at how much of a difference they can make.

 

FAQ.

Do wider car tires give you more grip?

A wider tire has more grip because it creates more contact patches with the ground and provides traction. However, a wider tire has less weight per square inch because of the relatively smaller contact patch than a narrow tire. On dry roads, wider tires provide better grip, but narrow tires provide better grip on icy and snowy roads. Moreover, tire material and tread patterns also affect tire grip. Therefore you have to consider all these conditions together to find the best grip tire for your car.

 

Are wider tires more comfortable?

There is no direct correlation between tire width and comfort. Tire comfort should be compared to its profile (aspect ratio). When the tire has a high profile, it has more air then absorbs more shocks. If we compare this, assuming only the tire width changes (wide aspect ratio and rim diameter are constant), wide tires have a higher profile. For example, the 265 /75-R16 vs 245/75-R16 tires have a slightly higher profile than the 265 wheels 245. So wide tires are a little more comfortable in this situation.

 

Why are wider tires more prone to hydroplaning?

When the tire has a larger patch, it will catch more water on the surface. Since it catches more water, it needs extra time to carry out the water on the road. Moreover, the tread pattern is also prone to hydroplane. Lug or block shape tread patterns tires perform well on wet roads.

 

Does hydroplaning mean I need new tires?

Yes. Hydroplaning happens when the tire treads wear out. Though if the tire has deeper treads, it can easily carry out the water on the road. However, brand new tires can hydroplane if you drive fast. The new tires have deep treads to remove water from the surface, but there is a limited time to push the water out of the tire during fast driving.

 

Is a wider tire better in the snow?

Wider tires do not perform better in snow and slippery roads. Wider tires perform best on dry roads, but snow roads need more friction than dry roads. Wider tires put a low-pressure square inch on the road (less friction). But narrow tires put higher surface pressure on the road (high friction). Therefore in winter, narrow tires perform better and are safer.

 

Is it ok to drive on winter tires in the summer?

Winter tires are specifically designed for freezing climates to improve grip. These wheels have soft tread, so tires wear out much faster in hot climates. Moreover, winter tires have extra grip, so acceleration may be slower, resulting in higher fuel consumption. Furthermore, it can result in skidding or loss of control. Therefore it is not the best practice to use winter tires in summer.

 

Do wider tires have more road noise?

Wider tires have more road noise because they have a larger contact patch area, more contact with the ground, and more sound. The tire tread pattern and noise have a close relation. When the tire tread has large air pockets, it generates more sounds. If the tire has a larger sidewall, it absorbs sound. If we compare 245 vs 255 tires, 255 wheels create more noise.

 

Do wide tires wear faster?

The wider tires have a larger contact patch than the narrow tire. When the tire has a larger contact area, it puts low pressure on the surface (low weight on square inch). Low pressure means less friction and generates less heat. Therefore wider tires wear slower than narrow tires.

 

Which factors affect rolling resistance?

Rolling resistance is caused by tire pressure, tire width, tire diameter, car weight, construction technology, and tire tread. It is not caused by friction; it is caused by deforming of tires. Due to the weight put on the tire, its patch area (footprint) bends, which causes rolling resistance. So narrow tires have higher rolling resistance.

Subscribe to Cars Reborn

Get latest posts to your email inbox.

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.

Leave a Comment!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

error: Content is protected !!